Contact
blog
IP2Innovate

IP2I's statement on the European Commission publication of the follow-up study on the application of the Directive on the Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights (IPRED)

BRUSSELS, 27 January 2026 - IP2I's statement on the European Commission publication of the follow-up study on the application of the Directive on the Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights (IPRED)

IP2I welcomes the publication of the independent study into the effectiveness of certain provisions of the Intellectual Property Rights Enforcement Directive (IPRED).

The study confirms what our members have been experiencing for years and continue to experience: the proportionality requirement set out in the IPRED is not applied to patent cases in Europe, and is particularly problematic in Germany. Courts are granting automatic permanent injunctions in nearly all patent infringement cases without assessing whether the remedy fits the circumstances.

The lack of application of proportionality to patent enforcement undermines Europe's ability to attract investment in innovative technologies. This directly affects our competitiveness.

The study outlines several ways to solve this urgent problem so as to simplify the regulatory environment for companies and support their competitiveness. IP2I believes modernising the 20-year-old IPRED through targeted legislative amendments is the right and most effective solution. Non-binding guidelines have proven ineffective in addressing this issue, as evidenced by the Commission's November 2017 IPRED guidance, which failed to improve the situation - a failure the study also acknowledges.

 

For further information, please contact:
Patrick Oliver, Executive Director, IP2Innovate
contact@ip2innovate.eu
+32 477 597065

Share

Other press releases

Patrick Oliver

Patent law reform strengthens Germany as a location for innovation; Europe needs to follow suit to enhance its competitiveness

Berlin, June 11th 2021 - The Bundestag today adopted legislation to modernise German patent law. The changes are an important step towards creating a better balance between patent protection and innovation protection. European patent law needs to follow Germany’s lead.
IP2Innovate

IP2Innovate calls on the European Commission to strengthen EU law to ensure a balanced patent system and enhance Europe’s competitiveness

BRUSSELS, 25 March 2024 - IP2Innovate is calling for targeted amendments to EU intellectual property law to ensure that European patent courts consider the proportionality of remedies in their handling of patent litigation cases. The proposed amendments will help create a more balanced patent system. This will spur innovation and, in turn, help to address Europe’s lagging competitiveness. The 2004 EU IP Rights Enforcement Directive (IPRED) requires that remedies for patent infringement be applied in a proportionate manner, but courts are handing out injunctions to patent owners in effect automatically, without considering the disproportionate impact that may result.
Managing IP

UPC take-up likely to be poor, say industry counsel

In its article on whether companies are likely to make use of the Unified Patent Court (UPC), Managing IP reports that implementers see the enforcement associated with the unitary patent as more of a threat than an opportunity due to the enormous number of applicable patents and therefore likely lawsuits for their infringement and associated defense.
Back to overview

Subscribe to our newsletter

Privacy policy

© IP2Innovate 2025 - Website door Two Impress